AG rules that City of Plum Grove cannot obstruct county roads

Pct. 3 workers on Tuesday remove barricades off of Paul Campbell Loop that lead into the Colony Ridge subdivisions. The City of Plum Grove closed three intersections after the City deemed the roads "illegal." However, an AG opinion received on Sept. 8 says the City of Plum Grove lacks the authority to close county roads.

UPDATE: After this story posted, Bluebonnet News was notified that CR 5000 also was opened Tuesday evening.

County workers for Pct. 3 made a surprise trip to Plum Grove Tuesday afternoon to remove barricades that blocked access to CR 3479 and CR 5017, both off of Paul Campbell Loop, after the County received a legal opinion from Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton authorizing the removal of the barricades and the mounds of aggregate that were placed in the intersections by contract workers for the City of Plum Grove.

On Aug. 17, Plum Grove City Council unanimously approved closing the two intersections, which blocked traffic from the Colony Ridge subdivisions south of the city, while the City purportedly made repairs to city streets. City leaders, led by Mayor Lee Ann Penton Walker, contended that the intersections were never authorized by Council prior to being built by the developer, Colony Ridge.

“The Attorney General told the County that we have the authority and duty to remove any obstructions on county roads. We have determined that the obstructions were clearly outside of city limits and were county roads that had been accepted previously by the County,” said County Attorney Matthew Poston.

The AG opinion prepared by Ryan M. Vassar, Deputy Attorney General for Legal Counsel, cites Chapter 251 of the Texas Transportation Code, and states that Plum Grove lacks jurisdiction over the property on which the obstructions were located.

“Accordingly, insofar as these two county roads are public roads subject to Chapter 251, the County must remove any obstructions on the roads,” Vassar wrote.

The removal of the barricades came after an emergency meeting by Liberty County Commissioners Court on Tuesday morning during which commissioners discussed legal remedies for the barricaded county roads.

While tensions have been steadily building in the Plum Grove community and the neighboring Colony Ridge communities, the situation came to a head on Sunday after three people were arrested – one for Aggravated Assault with a Deadly Weapon – following a confrontation over the barricaded roads.

“The County is very concerned about the volatility of the situation. We want to see peace,” said Poston.

One barricaded road – CR 5000 – remains closed for now, and Poston said it will likely involve litigation with the City of Plum Grove. Commissioners on Tuesday authorized Poston to secure legal counsel to represent the County.

When asked how much the legal battle will cost the County, Poston said any estimate would be pure speculation.

“It will not come cheap. We could be spending money more productively to find a solution, but instead the County is having to hire an attorney,” he said.

The reopening of CR 5000 is different from the other two roads because it has not been formally accepted by county commissioners as a county road.

While not specifically discussing CR 5000, Poston said the process for the County accepting a road first requires the county’s engineering firm, LJA, to first pass inspection on the construction of a road. Once engineers sign off on it, county commissioners must agree to oversee maintenance of the road.


Cleveland ISD Superintendent Chris Trotter spent several hours on Labor Day going over the logistics of new bus routes that were the result of the closure the three intersections in Plum Grove.

There are 20 school buses running four routes per day to serve the families of Plum Grove. While the two now-opened intersections will make it somewhat easier to bus children to and from school, Trotter is concerned about the additional wear and tear on the school buses as they are still being forced to detour around CR 5000, a wide boulevard that leads east and then south into the Colony Ridge communities. Taking CR 5000, located at the beginning of Plum Grove Road, allows the buses to miss some of the most heavily-damaged part of Plum Grove streets, some of which were significant damage caused by recent floods and a lack of maintenance.

“There’s about a one-mile stretch here where it tears up springs, front ends, back ends and tires, so we are struggling with that,” Trotter said. “So now we have to divert all the buses that would have taken CR 5000, which the City closed over the weekend, down Plum Grove Road. This is going to increase bus travel, which will increase mileage, which will increase fuel consumption, and then there is the potential for kids getting home from school late.”

Previous articleLiberty County Jail arrest report, Sept. 5, 2020
Next articleLiberty County Jail arrest report, Sept. 6, 2020
Before creating Bluebonnet News in 2018, Vanesa Brashier was a community editor for the Houston Chronicle/Houston Community Newspapers. During part of her 12 years at the newspapers, she was assigned as the digital editor and managing editor for the Humble Observer, Kingwood Observer, East Montgomery County Observer and the Lake Houston Observer, and the editor of the Dayton News, Cleveland Advocate and Eastex Advocate. Over the years, she has earned more than two dozen writing awards, including Journalist of the Year.


  1. What about the wear and tear on the vehicles (springs, front ends, back ends and tires) of the citizens of Plum Grove? We have been dealing with it for over three years now! It has cost me over $1500.00 to get repairs done on my auto. All we keep hearing is the city blaming the county and the county blaming the city! I hope the AG investigates what is going on down here. We are paying taxes to BOTH and not getting a thing for it! Someone needs to do something!

  2. I think the AG needs to look into all of the roads in NE Liberty County. They are all bad. Something has to give here. We all pay our taxes. Where is our money going?

    • Probably the same place all the money went that was supposed to go to refurbishing the two lane bridge over the Trinity in Liberty

    • Look at your tax bill. It all goes to the school. Stop voting in favor of the school bonds and our tax’s will quit going up. Then maybe they will focus on our roads.

      • Maybe if you voted for school bonds, they would have enough money to educate you on the proper use of the apostrophe.

  3. Where do I sign up for all my repairs to my two trucks for tires Sherlock brakes locking up and shocks and struts and dashboard cracked all to hell. Due to shaking the hell out my truck and not to mention my brakes and rotors from having to break so hard in big ass hole
    Out here… Complaint go unheard for years and I agree the roads are not safe. Hope someone gets their just desserts…

  4. It only took 3 people getting arrested and 1 being in the hospital for the commissioner to FINALLY come to plum grove and take down barracks!! Wonder what it will take to get him off his rear and actually fix a road?? Do you think Trey Harris will now be forced to take down all his PRIVATE ROAD signs for roads the judge declared County Roads?? (This same judge who hasn’t wanted to make any decisions until he had an emergency meeting with Trey Harris this week!!)

  5. It is not the commissioner’s doing’s as I said before, the Commissioner can only do what the “County” allows them to do! Need go higher up!

  6. So they called R5000 a CR even though there’s a HUGE sign beside it placed there by the developer claiming it to be a PRIVATE ROAD and no it’s not even been accepted as a county road… yet the state illegally labels it “CR5000” (even though it isn’t) gives it County Road Privileges and declares our city cannot legally close it down? Where did the rule of law go again???

    Apparently the corruption in Liberty County goes all the way to Austin now. Wow! :-O

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.